
Over the past two years, as the federal government moved against institutions across American life, many of the most powerful ones chose to comply. Philanthropy was in the crosshairs too: foundations funding equity and climate work were targeted directly, while the federal dollars many nonprofits depended on disappeared.
John Palfrey, president of the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, pushed his sector to step out from behind the scenes and take a public stand as a civic actor. He helped rally a broad coalition of foundations to defend the freedom to give and raised MacArthur’s own payout to at least 6% to help offset federal cuts. That leadership earned him Inside Philanthropy’s 2025 Foundation Leader of the Year award, along with spots on the TIME100 Philanthropy list and U.S. News & World Report’s Best Leaders of 2025.
Long before he led one of the country’s largest foundations, John was a leading figure in the connected learning community. He has written influential books on digital youth culture and parenting, and has led organizations that have been central to the connected learning movement, including Harvard’s Berkman Klein Center and Andover. At Andover, he launched the Tang Institute dedicated to innovative approaches inspired by connected learning.
In this Q&A, John describes how philanthropy has met the moment in this tumultuous time, how it still needs to evolve, and he offers advice for grant-seekers on where to look for support beyond the best-known foundations.
Question: What’s the critical issue?
John Palfrey: When our politics first took a turn toward the authoritarian, let’s call it 10 years ago, many of my peers in philanthropy did not see it coming. I admit, I did not expect it either. But when 2024 came along, we were not flat-footed. We knew there could be real disruption to the core work that we were doing: anything to do with racial equity, anything to do with climate, would be facing a challenging environment.
And so a group of us with longstanding relationships in philanthropy decided that we were going to take a different approach from what we were seeing in universities, law firms, and businesses. As students of Timothy Snyder’s On Tyranny — that first chapter is entitled “Don’t Obey in Advance” — we came into 2025 ready to to unite in advance as a sector. A core group of quite large foundations with a broad ideological spread decided that we were going to stand together and lean into our power in a way that’s not typical in philanthropy: to see ourselves as actors in the civic play, more than just the funders of those who were. That was an important shift.
At the start of the current administration, right off the bat, there were executive orders that targeted us pretty explicitly. There were clear indications that we, as a sector, were in the administration’s crosshairs. Years later, I really hope we’ve passed the peak of fear. And the fear is quite real. It’s not for nothing. There have been death threats to people in our sector. There have been threats to burn down our buildings. There are state attorneys general who have come after donors, specifically for things they’ve been doing that are thought to be contrary to public policy. So let me take the fears seriously.
But we’ve been successful in terms of defense. The administration’s attacks, which are completely inconsistent with the First Amendment, have not really stuck. It’s not like the saber rattling has ended — they continue to suggest that they will go after certain organizations and try to take away their 501(c)3 tax status — but I would say in a defensive way, it has proved that standing together and leaning into our strength as civic actors has been successful.
Q: How could philanthropy be doing better?
John: There are all sorts of other ways in which we haven’t been successful. I don’t think we’ve given away enough money as a sector. I don’t think we have engaged enough with supporting all of our grantees as a sector. The Center for Effective Philanthropy reports have empirically shown that grantees feel they are not being supported by their funders while they are under attack. Despite the success of our defensive moves to support the sector, there are lots of ways we haven’t met the moment.
There’s more money out there than there’s ever been for philanthropy, and we are giving away more money every year. But there’s so much more that could be given. There are more ideas than ever, and there should be more financial support for them.
There are so many places that are hurting from this administration’s cuts. There are literally no US dollars in foreign aid. Literally no dollars federally in public media. These are things the government has funded for decades. Setting aside issues that might be seen as politically sensitive, these things used to be basic, but are now zeroed out in terms of funding. I am hoping that we are building from a very, very low moment to a better place where we’re not just filling holes because we’ve had to.
Q: What is your advice for grant-seekers?
John: There is more opportunity out there than a few dozen well-known foundations with big budgets. There are over 100,000 foundations in America alone. And most new money today is not going into foundations: it’s going into donor-advised funds and into LLCs. Families are giving through different mechanisms.
As president of one of the large and well-known foundations, there are many people who want to get just a half hour on my calendar to share their ideas. But the MacArthur Foundation does about 400-500 grants a year. The surface area for grant-seekers to find opportunities is much bigger than the aperture of a foundation president’s calendar.
I’m not saying don’t call MacArthur Foundation. Of course, we want to talk to as many people as we can, but it’s literally not possible to talk to everyone. And particularly with the amount of new wealth that’s been created in the tech sector and on the left coast, there is a lot of money and a lot of people open to really great ideas. If you can connect with the right people and have a meeting of the minds, there are foundations and families who might be there with you for the long run.
Q: How does the philanthropy sector need to evolve?
John: Over time, I hope that it’s possible for us to surface better matching between really good ideas and those who might be the right next funder for it. I think that technology, if structured in an open and thoughtful way, could be helpful to that.
There are a few networks, particularly of high net worth families, that I think are doing a really good job sharing knowledge and connections. Forward Global is one example of a network model that I think will bear fruit.
At the MacArthur Foundation we are building the Philanthropy Data Commons. It’s still in a very early stage, but the idea is that philanthropy should have a common application that helps share information. Universities have had this for a long time. The prototype version has MacArthur’s data so far.
Another model to keep an eye on: a nonprofit called Lever for Change. It is a platform for funders who may want to make investments, particularly in an area where they may not know all the grantees. They can announce an open call with a certain amount of money, and then have anybody apply. Each challenge can fund only a certain number of applications, but the platform then creates a database “of top applicants in a Lever for Change competition,” called the Bold Solutions Network. Whether or not the applicants get funded in a given call, the database holds up their ideas and shows that a vetted group of experts has said: this is really promising. Ideally, as more funders come online with additional wealth, that’s another mechanism for matchmaking on that wider surface area of opportunity.
This Q&A was originally published in Kaleidoscope, the monthly Q&A series powered by the Connected Learning Alliance. Subscribe to Kaleidoscope on LinkedIn or sign up for the CLA’s newsletter to get the next conversation in your inbox.


